The Holiday Table You're Allowed to Set (or Reset)
Because tradition should not require abandoning yourself.
November 2026 Newsletter
As November arrives, the holiday season begins to make itself known. Invitations are extended, family gatherings are planned, and familiar traditions begin to take shape. For some, this time of year brings warmth, nostalgia, and anticipation. For others, it brings something far more complicated: anxiety, obligation, guilt, and the familiar emotional weight of relationships that have historically taken more than they have given.
We often hear that the holidays are about family. But perhaps an equally important question is: What does family mean to you, and how do you feel when you’re with yours?
What if this holiday season, instead of automatically asking, “What are we supposed to do?” you gave yourself permission to ask, “What would actually feel meaningful, nourishing, and authentic to me?”
When Family Traditions Come at an Emotional Cost
For adult children of emotionally immature parents, the holiday season can activate longstanding relational patterns.
Emotionally immature parents may struggle to recognize their adult children’s emotional needs, tolerate differences of opinion, respect boundaries, or accept that their children have grown into independent people with their own preferences, values, and lives.
Growing up in these environments, children may learn that maintaining connection requires keeping the peace, managing a parent’s emotions, suppressing their own needs, or becoming exceptionally good at avoiding disappointment.
These survival strategies can follow us well into adulthood.
Suddenly, a simple decision about where to spend Thanksgiving becomes something much bigger.
“But Mom will be upset.”
“Grandma will make me feel guilty.”
“It’s what we’ve always done.”
“I just don’t want to deal with the fallout.”
And so, year after year, we may find ourselves participating in traditions that leave us emotionally depleted, resentful, anxious, or disconnected from ourselves.
Here is a question worth sitting with:
How much of yourself are you willing to sacrifice to protect someone else from the discomfort of your choices?
There is an important distinction between choosing to compromise out of love and feeling compelled to self-abandon out of fear, obligation, or guilt.
Creating Change Through Courage, Compassion, and Connection
At The Montclair Therapist, we believe meaningful change begins when we develop the psychological flexibility to make choices guided by our values rather than dictated by uncomfortable emotions.
Courage may look like doing something differently this year. Perhaps declining an invitation, shortening a visit, establishing a boundary, or starting an entirely new tradition. Courage doesn’t necessarily mean feeling confident or guilt-free. Sometimes, it means allowing guilt to accompany you without giving it the authority to make your decisions.
Compassion means recognizing that changing family patterns can be genuinely painful. You may love your parents and still acknowledge the emotional toll of spending time with them. You may grieve the family relationships you wish you had while accepting the relationships that actually exist. Two things can be true.
Connection invites us to broaden our understanding of what family can look like. Biological relationships do not automatically guarantee emotional safety, belonging, or reciprocity. Sometimes our most nourishing connections exist outside the family we were born into.
What If You Created a Different Kind of Holiday?
Perhaps your holiday table looks different this year.
Maybe it’s filled with close friends who have become family. Maybe it’s a smaller gathering with extended relatives who make you feel seen, valued, and accepted. Perhaps it’s coworkers, neighbors, or people who have shown up for you in meaningful ways.
Maybe your holiday includes volunteering at a local soup kitchen, giving back to your community, taking a quiet trip, or spending an intentionally peaceful day at home.
Or perhaps you still attend the traditional family gathering, but this time with clearer boundaries and permission to leave when you’ve had enough.
The point is not to replace one rigid set of holiday expectations with another. It’s to recognize that you have choices.
Traditions can be beautiful. They connect us to our histories and to the people we love. But traditions are also allowed to evolve as we do.
A Little Something to Reflect On This November
Before the holiday season gains momentum, consider asking yourself:
- Am I making holiday plans from a place of genuine desire, or from fear of disappointing someone?
- Which relationships leave me feeling connected and nourished, and which leave me feeling depleted or emotionally responsible for others?
- If guilt weren’t making the decisions, what might I choose differently?
- What is one small, courageous way I can honor both my relationships and my own emotional well-being this holiday season?
Remember, feeling guilty does not automatically mean you have done something wrong. Sometimes guilt is simply the unfamiliar emotional experience of choosing yourself when you’ve spent much of your life choosing everyone else.
A Final Thought From The Montclair Therapist
This November, I invite you to consider that perhaps the most meaningful holiday tradition isn’t one that has been passed down through generations.
Perhaps it’s the one you courageously begin yourself.
One rooted in compassion rather than obligation. In connection rather than performance. In authenticity rather than self-abandonment.
You do not have to stop loving your family to begin honoring yourself.
And you do not have to keep doing something simply because it’s what you’ve always done.
After all, creating change sometimes begins with having the courage to set a different table.
About the Author
Dr. Amanda Aster McKenna, Psy.D. is a Licensed Psychologist based in Montclair, NJ, providing both in-person and virtual therapy across all PSYPACT states (see full list here).
She specializes in Trauma-Informed Care, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), and Compassion-Focused Therapy (CFT).
In addition to her clinical practice, Dr. McKenna is a professor of psychology at Kean University in Union, NJ — and a proud working mom to three beautiful children.
If the approaching holiday season is bringing up difficult family dynamics, guilt, or longstanding relationship patterns, therapy can offer a supportive space to explore them. At The Montclair Therapist, we help individuals build healthier boundaries, reconnect with their values, and create more authentic relationships—with others and with themselves.
Until next month,
Your favorite enabler of Mental Wellness
The Montclair Therapist
Dr. Amanda Aster-McKenna, Psy.D.
(She/Her/Hers)
NJ Licensed Psychologist #5888, Private Practice, Montclair, NJ
Adjunct Professor, Kean University, Department of Advanced Studies in Psychology
Manager, New York City Chapter of the Association for Contextual Behavioral Science
Board Member, Mental Health Association of Essex and Morris
*Peace, Love, & Fierce Acceptance*
If you would like to sign up for my monthly newsletter, please email [email protected] to be added to the mailing list.
